RealTorch / Field Guide / Estimating

05 / 15   The 15 Functions of a Homebuilding Company

Estimating for Home Builders

Estimating translates a product into work the company can buy, schedule, build, invoice, and learn from.

“Smarter estimating can make your life simpler and easier, and increase your productivity and profits.”
Al Trellis, Estimating section, IBS 2019

At a glance.

What this function decides
Estimating decides how much detail the current decision needs and whether the estimate is ready to use. It also owns the scope, quantities, price sources, cost codes, allowances, contingency, and open items behind the total.
What you need to know
The estimate needs current plans, specifications, selections, site facts, and a complete scope. Add current quotes and fees, approved changes, commitments, recent actual costs, unpaid work, and the company's cost codes.
What good work produces
Good work produces an estimate another person can trace. It shows which documents were used, what is included, where each important number came from, what remains open, who approved it, and how it compares with actual cost.

A worked example.

Atlas compares the estimate with current plans, bids, commitments, and actual costs to show what truly changed.

RealTorch Atlas
Review the Bellamy estimate as a construction-planning estimate. Compare it with plan revision 7, the scope list, current bids, approved changes, commitments, unpaid work, and actual costs from the last six homes. Leave the estimate now in use unchanged and create a separate draft. For each difference, tell me whether it comes from quantity, unit price, added scope, an allowance, field work, timing, coding, or an open question. Show the source, date, and strength of evidence for every important finding.
  • Bellamy_Estimate_In_Use.xlsx
  • Bellamy_Plan_Rev_7.pdf
  • Bellamy_Scope_Register.xlsx
  • Current_Bids_Q3.xlsx
  • Approved_Changes_Commitments_and_Accruals.xlsx
  • Job_Cost_Detail_Last_6.xlsx
Atlas

Tools and sources used

File Retrieval6
File Retrieval

The current estimate and the records that should agree with it.

Used
Estimate, plan revision, scope register, current bids, approved changes, commitments, accrual status, and six recent job-cost ledgers.
Did
Retrieved the six named sources into the working context and preserved the current revision and as-of dates.
Supports
The source records used to classify unit-price, coding, scope-gap, timing, and unresolved findings.
PDF Page Inspection
PDF Page Inspection

A visual review of the current plan revision.

Used
Plan sheets A4.2 and C1.1 plus the revision notes in the supplied set.
Did
Inspected sheets A4.2 and C1.1 and captured the visible garage-door and retaining conditions for cross-file comparison.
Supports
The location of the two conditions in the plans. The cross-file analysis shows whether they appear in the estimate and bid list.
Builder Knowledge Lookup
Builder Knowledge Lookup

Function 05: Estimating, together with Purchasing and Accounting guidance.

Used
Atlas's Estimating guidance on complete, organized, accurate, and timely estimates, together with Purchasing guidance on current scope and bids and Accounting guidance on commitments and actual costs.
Did
Used the same cost codes across the estimate and actual records, then separated quantity, unit price, scope, allowance, field, timing, coding, and open questions.
Supports
The type of estimate, the reasons for each change, the strength of the evidence, and the items an estimator must confirm.
Running Analysis
Running Analysis

A comparison of the estimate with current bids and actual costs.

Used
Estimate lines, bid rows and dates, scope ownership, approved changes, commitments, accrual status, transaction descriptions, cost codes, and actuals from six homes.
Did
Matched the records, recalculated the priced draft, explained why the estimate changed, isolated the repeated $17,800 per-home code shift, flagged unpriced work, rated the evidence, and generated the workbook.
Supports
The $12,400 unit-price update, the absence of other supported adjustments, every table row, and Bellamy_Estimate_Reconciliation.xlsx.
Saving File
Saving File

A draft estimate that preserves sources and unresolved work.

Used
The in-use estimate, construction-planning draft, source dates, strength of evidence, proposed updates, open questions, and the people responsible for confirming them.
Did
Saved Bellamy_Estimate_Reconciliation.xlsx to the company's file library.
Supports
The saved workbook represented by the preview, with original, draft, source-map, and unresolved-scope tabs.

$12,400 is a real cost update. The $17,800 foundation variance is a coding problem.

The in-use estimate is $395,800. The construction-planning draft as of August 12 is $408,200 before two unresolved scope items. Current framing, drywall, and mechanical bids add $7,400, $2,200, and $2,800. Those are true unit-price updates totaling $12,400. The recurring foundation overrun is different. Clearing and rough-grading invoices average $17,800 per home across six recent homes. Those invoices were posted to code 03, while the estimate carries that scope in code 02. Moving the cost between codes changes the category variance but does not change total cost. Plan revision 7 also shows a garage service door and a rear retaining condition with no priced line in the estimate or bid register. Both remain open until the estimator and trades price the scope. The supplied records support no separate quantity, allowance, approved-change, field-loss, or timing adjustment.

XLSBellamy_Estimate_Reconciliation.xlsx6 sources and 6 recent homes
FindingSourceType of changeStrength of evidenceDraft effectNext action
Clearing and rough grading posted to code 036 job-cost ledgers and estimate codes 02 and 03CodingHigh. Repeated on 6 homes.$0 totalReclassify in the draft. Controller validates the posting rule.
Framing and lumber bid updateHalloran bid dated Aug 6 and scope row 0610Unit priceHigh. Current written bid.+$7,400Update draft after purchasing confirms term
Drywall and finish bid updateCurrent bid and scope row 0925Unit priceHigh. Current written bid.+$2,200Update draft
Mechanical bid updateCurrent HVAC and plumbing bidsUnit priceHigh. Current written bids.+$2,800Update draft
Garage service doorPlan Rev 7, A4.2. No priced scope line.Scope gapHigh on the gap. Cost is unresolved.TBDEstimator assigns scope and requests price
Rear retaining conditionPlan Rev 7, C1.1. No allowance or bid.UnresolvedLow. Site applicability is unconfirmed.TBDConfirm site applicability before pricing
Source-supported priced subtotalCurrent priced scope onlyPriced draft subtotalMedium. Two items remain open.$408,200Resolve and price the open scope before the estimate is approved